10 Best Pizza Pan 2020 – Expert Reviews & Guide

Pizza is one of the most favourite food available on the market today, yes, in the recent times the demand for pizza have increased exponentially and this have led people to bake their own pizza at home. However, the baking process is done, the total price baking a pizza at home is comparatively very cheap than buying it from a restaurant.

This is one of the main reasons why the demands for pizza pans have increased the past few years. As the demand as increased over the past few years, the number of brands that markets pizza pans have also increased. Selecting the best pizza pan from the long list of products on the market today is not an easy task, this is why we have tried and selected few pizza pans available on the market today.

Here is the list of 10 best pizza pans available on the market today

1. Lodge P14P3 Pro-Logic Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Lodge P14P3 Pro-Logic Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

Are you looking for the best pizza pan on the market today? If yes, then you would already know that Lodge is one of the most reputed bakeware and cookware manufacturing brand in the world and this pizza pan comes from the same brand.

Baking itself is a simple process, but, if the pan used for baking is inefficient, the entire process could be a waste, this is why it is very important that you consider purchasing a pizza pan from a reputed brand and a product with best features. This pizza pan comes with a 14-gauge thickness and it is designed in such a way that it can bake the pizza with ease and even at a comparatively faster phase. This product is made of cast-iron and it should be pre-seasoned vegetable oil for maximum non-stick feature. This pizza pan has side loop hands that can help the user transfer the pan from one place to another with ease. The manufacturer offers a lifetime warranty on this product.

Things we liked

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Side loop handles
  • Secure grip
  • Pre-seasoned pan
  • 14-inch cast iron
  • Heats quickly
  • Can handle up to 400 degree Fahrenheit

Things we did not like

  • This pizza pan can be washed only with hand

2. Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic Non-stick Bakeware

Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef

Buy From Amazon

You might have already heard of the brand name Cuisinart, this is one of the top bakeware, cookware, an kitchen appliances manufacturing brand in the world today. If you are looking for a pizza pan that can last for a long time without deforming or rusting, then this product is the best choice for you.

This product comes in a 14-gauge specification and the surface of this pizza pan is perforated. Yes, this is a perforated pizza pan that can help you bake crispy crust pizza. This pizza pan is made of heavy gauge steel aluminized to offer maximum even heating. This pizza pan comes with a lifetime warranty and the product is designed to be dishwasher safe. This pizza pan comes with thick rolled edges that can prevent the pan from wrapping at high temperature.

Things we liked

  • Dishwasher safe
  • 14-gauge thickness
  • Heavy gauge aluminium
  • Thick rolled edges
  • Non-stick features incorporated
  • Easy to clean
  • Perforated surface for maximum efficient baking

Things we did not like

  • Since the product is made of aluminium after prolonged use, a coating will form on the surface, which could be harmful for health

3. Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

This pizza pan comes from the brand Home-Complete and it is one of the best products available on the market today. However, most of you would not be familiar with this brand, but, to our expertise and test this product is the best at what it does.

This is a 14-inch pizza pan that is made of high quality cast iron that can evenly bake your pizza with minimum effort. One of the notable things about this pizza pan is that the cast iron used to manufacture this pan can offer authentic pizza flavour and it is coated to avoid rusting or change in texture. This pizza pan comes pre-seasoned with vegetable oil to offer maximum non-stick property. Yet another ting about this pizza pan is that it comes in a simple design that makes it easy to clean. The manufacturer offers a 10-year limited warranty on this product.

Things we liked

  • Made of high-quality cast iron
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • Pre-seasoned for maximum non-stick feature
  • 14-gauge aluminized steel
  • Designed to spread heat evenly

Things we did not like

  • Few customers have reviewed the product to come with inconsistent surface

4. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Pizza Pan

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

OXO is yet another top bakeware manufacturing and marketing brand on today’s market. This pizza pan comes made for long-lasting and to help anyone cook tastier pizza with ease.

This pizza pan come made of commercial-grade aluminized steel that comes designed in such a way that it can spread the heat evenly for better baking experience. This product offers more durability and stability at the same time. One of the notable things about this pizza pan is that it comes with Swiss-engineered PTFE coating that makes this pan non-stick for easy release of pizza from the pan after baking. Comes with squared rolled edges to prevent the pan from wrapping during baking process. Yet another important feature that comes incorporated into this pizza pan is the micro-textured pattern on its surface that enables heavy air circulation.The manufacturer offers a lifetime replacement warranty on this product.

Things we liked

  • Made of commercial-grade heavy gauge aluminized steel
  • Designed to spread heat evenly on its surface
  • Rolled edges to avoid wrapping
  • Micro-textured for maximum air circulation while baking
  • Lifetime replacement warranty
  • Durable and stable at the same time

Things we did not like

  • This pizza pan is not dishwasher safe

5. ProBake Teflon Non-Stick 12″ Pizza Pan

ProBake Teflon Non-Stick

Buy From Amazon

Like the brand name itself suggests this product is designed for expert cooks and for customers who required professional used pizza pans. This pizza pan comes in a unique design that includes style and quality at a reasonable price.

This pizza pan comes made of 12 gauge high-quality weight steel that is coated with Teflon Xtra non-stick that will enable the pizza to come off from the pan after baking. The non-stick coating on this product is of high-quality and therefore, the surface is scratch proof. This pizza pan comes with raised edges that will keep the dough at place and give the pizza better shape.This product comes manufactured in The United States of America. One of the best things about this product is that it comes with corrosion-resistant design.

Things we liked

  • Non-stick finish
  • High-quality steel construction
  • Raised edges for better shape
  • Made of American
  • 12-inch gauge
  • Scratch-resistant surface

Things we did not like

  • Even though this is a 12-gauge, the diameter of the pan is comparatively low

6. Chicago Metallic 16124 Professional Non-Stick Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Chicago Metallic 16124 Professional Non-Stick Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

This is a 14-inch diameter pizza pan that we tested recently, when compared other products available on the market today, this pizza pan is better and efficient.

This pizza pan comes designed in Chicago deep style that makes this pizza pan suitable to be used for different purposes like cooking cookies, stuffed pizza, and pie. This pizza pan is durable and strong at the same time, the entire product comes made of heavy duty carbon steel that is tested and certified to be the best available today. This bakeware comes with non-stick coating that makes the baking easy and cleaning easy too. This pizza pan is designed in such a way that it can be cleaned with ease. However, this product is not dishwasher safe.

Things we liked

  • 14-inch diameter
  • Made of high quality heavy duty carbon steel
  • Non stick coating for easy release of pizza
  • Designed for cooking or baking more than just pizza
  • Easy to clean
  • Chicago deep dish design

Things we did not like

  • The customer service offered by the brand is comparatively poor than other brands

7. Wilton 2105-6804 Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

Wilton 2105-6804 Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

Buy From Amazon

This is a perforated pizza pan that is designed to make your pizza crust crispy and tasty at the same time. Wilton is a renowned brand that has a legacy of manufacturing high-quality bakeware’s and this product is no different.

This perforated pizza pan can help you bake pizzas with crispy crust and with unique taste. This pizza pan has a non-stick coating over it that enables the user release the pizza from the pan with ease. This pizza pan has round shape with round loop handles incorporated on two sides for easy handling of the pan. The overall diameter of this pan is 14-inches and the manufacturer offers a 10-year limited warranty on this product. This pizza pan is dishwasher safe and the user can use soap on this product without destroying the coating on the pan. One of the notable things about this pizza pan is that, you wont be able to find any pizza screen with both perforation and non-stick feature together.

Things we liked

  • Perforated pizza pan
  • Comes with loop handles on two sides
  • Non-stick coating on surface for easy release of pizza after baking
  • Has an overall diameter of 14-inches
  • Manufacturer offers a 10-year limited warranty
  • Dishwasher safe product

Things we did not like

  • Nothing as such

8. Maxi Nature Kitchenware Pizza Pans with holes

Pack of 2 Pizza Pans

Buy From Amazon

This pizza pan comes from a new brand, yet, in our test, we found that this product is comparatively better than most of the products available today.

This product is perforated and it is one of the best-perforated pizza pans that you can consider purchasing today. This product comes with a non-stick coating that enables the pizza to come off from the pan with ease after baking. According to the manufacturer, this pizza pan is one of the best selling products in the UK and the product is designed for professional daily use. One of the notable things about this product is that the manufacturer offers 60-days money-back guarantee on this product.

Things we liked

  • Designed for even heat distribution
  • Non-stick coating for easy release of pizza after baking
  • Made of superior quality steel
  • Strong and durable
  • Money-back guarantee
  • Sturdy built
  • Easy to clean
  • Best selling product in the UK

Things we did not like

  • Few of the customers have reviewed the product to loosing the non-stick coating after a few weeks use.

9. American Metalcraft TP18 TP Series 18-Gauge Aluminium Pizza Pan

American Metalcraft Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

This pizza pan comes from the top brand American Metalcraft and it is one of the best products that you can consider purchasing today. This pizza pan comes with an overall diameter of 18-inches and it is designed for baking and serving. The entire product comes made of 18-gauge aluminium that has a property of spreading the heat evenly all over the surface with ease. This pizza pan comes with raised edges that will keep the dough in place and give shape to the pizza.However, there is one thing that you should know, this pizza pan is not dishwasher safe, the user will have to hand wash it.

Things we liked

  • 18-inch diameter
  • Can be used to prepare, bake, and serve pizza
  • Raised edges
  • Best for extra-extra-large
  • 18-gauge aluminium made product
  • Sturdy and reliable construction
  • Designed in such a way that it can spread the heat evenly over the surface of the pan

Things we did not like

  • This pan can be hand washed only

10. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pizza Pan

USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pizza Pan

Buy From Amazon

This product comes made with commercial grade and heavy gauge metal that is certified to last long without deforming and rusting under any circumstances. This pizza pan comes with a corrugated surfacee design that allows better airflow during baking. The manufacturer offers a lifetime warranty on this product. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes with a non-stick coating that will help in the easy release of pizza after baking.

Things we liked

  • Corrugated surface for maximum airflow while baking
  • The non-stick coating that can enable easy release of pizza after baking
  • Made of recycled steel
  • BPA free product
  • 14-inch diameter
  • The heavy gauge and commercial-grade steel used
  • Limited lifetime warranty

Things we did not like

  • Nothing as such

Pizza Pan Buying Guide – Features To Consider While Buying It?

Pizza is one of the most favorite and most wanted food around the world today. There was a time when baking/making pizza was not common and pizzas were available only at specific restaurants. However, today with the increase in the influence of social media and online tutorials, more people plan on baking/cooking pizza and this is the reason why there are more than one type of pizza pan and more than 10 different pizza pan brands on the market today. This buying guide will help you select the best pizza pan from the market today.

Before checking the market for the best pizza pan, you should know that there are different types of pizza pans available on the market today and each type of pan has its own advantage and its disadvantage.

Types of pizza pan

  • Deep dish pizza pan:- deep-dish pizza pans is a traditional type of pizza pan available on the market even today. This type of pizza pan is distinctive in design when compared to other pizza pans, as this type of pan comes with hard and high metal sides. The deep-dish pizza pan is available in both square and round shape, and it could be made of aluminium, non-stick, or stainless steel plated with tin. Deep dish pizza pans are best recommended for commercial oven baking.
  • Disk or pizza screens:- if you need to make the baking process to be fast and easy, then pizza screen or disk is the best option or you. This type of pizza pan comes designed in such a way that if used on the conveyor pizza oven, the baking process will take comparatively very less time. When it comes to design, this pizza pan have a mesh bottom that makes the heat transfer from oven to dough easy and the same mesh feature helps to make the pizza crispy and tasty.
  • Stone pizza pan:- if you ask us which type of pizza pan to select and purchase, we would recommend going for a stone pizza pan as it offers pizzas with different taste. However, when compared to other types of pizza pans is expensive. A stone pizza pan could be made of ceramic or cordierite, the small pores on the stone absorbs the extra moisture from the dough and this, in turn, will make the crust of the pizza crispy. Unlike most of the pizza pans, a stone pizza pan will help make the pizza taste better and unique.
  • Cast iron pizza pans:- A cast iron pizza pan is the most versatile pizza pans available on the market today. A cast iron pizza pan can be used on a grill, in a broiler, a stovetop, or in the oven. A cast iron pizza pan comes with its edges slightly raised that will offer structure to the pizza crust. Even though, a cast iron pizza pan is heavy, it is one of the best pizza pans as it can hold heat for a long time.
  • CAR pizza pan:- CAR pizza pan comes made in a way that it can bake rolled or sheeted dough in to tasty pizza with crispy crust. This type of pizza pan helps lift the edges of the pizza crust and make it look sharp and also tasty at the same time.
  • Wide rim pizza pan:- This type of pizza pan is similar to regular pizza pans, however, this one is wider and it helps baking pizza easy and slicing the pizza even easier. The same pizza pan can be used to serve the pizza on the table.
  • The thickness of the pizza pan:- Most of the people think that the thickness of pizza pan is not important, however, that is a wrong assumption. Under no circumstances, the customer should not neglect this factor.Pizza pans come in different thickness, thick pans take longer time to cook/bake, on the other hand, if the pan is thin, then the pizza will be baked within the leas time. So based on how long you need your pizza baked, you can select the best suitable pizza pan from the market.If you do not know how to select, then, all you have to do is simply check the specifications for the gauge, a pizza pan might have a gauge between 12 to 26 or more. However, if you are a beginner, then we recommend that you go for 18 gauge pizza pan.

Type of pan surface

As already seen in the type of pizza pans section, you will know that there are different type of pizza pans based on the shape and size of the pan. Likewise, a pizza pan can be differentiated based on the type of surface of the pan.

  • Solid pizza pan:- this type of pizza pan, as the name itself suggests comes with a solid surface and it is one of the most common type of pizza pan used all over the world. However, this type of pizza pan takes comparatively more time then other types of pan.
  • Perforated pizza pans:- this type of pizza pans come with its surface full of holes that enables the heat to easily transfer from the over to the dough and therefore, make the baking easy and efficient.
  • Nibbed type:- this type of pizza pans come with its surface filled with bumps that is planted in such a way that it can allow airflow under the dough while baking, this feature, in turn, makes the crust of the pizza crispier and tasty.
  • Super perforated pizza pan:- this type of pizza pan is almost like the perforated pizza pa itself, however, the holes on the surface of the pizza is comparatively larger and they make the transfer of heat from the oven to dough easier. This feature, in turn, makes the pizza crust very much crispier.
  • Building material type:- a pizza pan can be made of different materials and it all depends on the brand and the designer.

Dark coated and light coated pizza pans

Both types of the pan have their own advantages and disadvantages. If you purchase a dark-coated pizza pan, then it can help you bake your pizza with ease as dark-coated pizza pan retains more heat than the light coated pan. On the other hand, light coated pizza pans slow down the baking process, but some people require their pizza baked slowly, such people can consider purchasing light coated pizza pan.

Anodized hard-coated pizza pan

If you are looking for a pizza pan that comes with style and quality at the same time, then anodized hard coated pizza pans are the best for you, this type of pizza pans can bake your pizza in comparatively less time as they come with a dark coating which retains comparatively more heat.

Silicone coated and uncoated pizza pans

Silicone coated pizza pans are those pizza pans that come with both the anodized hard coating and above this coating a silicon layer is added which helps the pizza to come off the pan with ease. Using this type of pizza pan can reduce the use of lubricants like oil, ghee, or cheese up to 50%. On the other hand, uncoated pizza pans are comparatively lighter coloured and this increases the baking time as this type of pizza pan cannot retain much heat. Uncoated pizza pans have a great disadvantage as they have to be seasoned every time before use.

To help you select and maintain a pizza pan for a long time, here are some facts that you should know.

Which product to purchase a pizza pan or pizza screen?

Answer: we have already mentioned about pizza pans above and the types of pizza pans available, the difference can be based on size, shape, and colour itself. However, we can differentiate them as pizza pan and pizza screen. The ones with a solid surface can be referred generally as pizza pans and the ones with perforation can be termed as pizza screen.

Here are the advantages and disadvantages of pizza pans:

Advantages of pizza pan

  • Comes in regular shape and size
  • Easy to use and they are durable as well
  • It is easier to serve pizza on a pizza pan
  • The user does not have to transfer the pizza from the pizza pan to another tray as the pan itself serves the purpose.

Disadvantages of pizza pan

  • Offers less ventilation to the dough while baking
  • Aluminium pizza pans are widely used today and they tend of foam a coating on the top after several uses and this coating can be harmful to health, so the user will have to provide anodize coating on the pan frequently.

Advantages of pizza screen

  • Helps to make the pizza crust crispy
  • It is lightweight
  • Offer maximum untilation for the dough
  • Can help transfer maximum heat from oven to dough
  • Can bake pizza faster
  • Very efficient and time-saving than most of the pans

Disadvantages of pizza screen

  • Pizza screen can be used only to bake pizza and nothing else, you cannot use the screen to cook pie or cake as the dough or the toppings can fall off through the holes
  • Pizza screen is not suitable and designed to be an alternative for serving tray, so if the user need to serve a pizza bakes on a pizza screen, he/she should transfer the pizza to a tray first.

Once you have successfully purchase a pizza pan, you should know that however, good the product might be, the user must pay an extra attention to clean the pan every time. If not, the lifetime of the pan keeps reducing. Here is how to clean the pizza pan after use

Step 1: take a gallon of water and add 2 cups of high-quality white vinegar into it.

Step 2: boil the solution slightly

Step 3: now take a large utensil or plug the sink in such a way that you can fill it with this vinegar solution

Step 4: dip the pizza pan into the solution and them move, rotate, twirl the pan in such a way that the entire pan is soaked in the solution.

Step 5: leave the pan in the solution, till until solution cools down.

Step 6: once the solution cools completely, remove the pan from it and then sprinkle baking soda on the pan. Now you will hear a fizzing sound, this frizzing sound means the vinegar has started to lose the grease on the pan and baking soda is clearing the residues from the pan

Step 7: once the frizzing sound fades, wipe to clean the pan and then rinse the pan. Now wipe to dry the pan and store the pan in a dry place until next use.

Conclusion

Purchasing a pizza pan from the market is not an easy task today, if you have already read the buying guide and the facts mentioned above, you would already understood that. However, there is nothing to worry about, to make things easier for you, we have tested and selected a few of the best pizza pans available today. Consider purchasing any one of the product listed above and you will not regret it.

Reply